Friday, January 4, 2013

Bluebeards and Blackbeard

Many well-known fairy tale figures become universally known and can be used as a reference to another story that contains the same basic story element: a rise in status or "rags-to-riches" story can be a Cinderella story, anyone marrying outisde of their social or perceived physical station is a Beauty or a Beast, etc. Darker elements can be labelled with fairy tale names as well-male predators are often compared to the wolf in Little Red Riding Hood, and serial killers sometimes bear the title Bluebeard.

Blackbeard the pirate, or Edward Teach, has often been confused with Bluebeard-often unintentionally, but sometimes intentionally by writers who link the the actual pirate with the character. In a time when most men were clean-shaven, both men terrified listeners with their odd beards-Blackbeard's grew all over his face, and he would even light slow-burning fuse cords under his hat so that his beard would appear to be burning and smoke would rise out of it.

The two bearded men were contemporaries-Blackbeard terrorized the seas in the late 17th/early 18th centuries, and Charles Perrault's "Bluebeard" appeared in France in 1697. Blackbeard sources pretty unanimously agree that he had fourteen wives. Although he did not likely murder them like Bluebeard, but married polygamously, his treatment of his wives was cruel-his last wife, a 16-year-old planter's daughter, he forced to prostitute herself to several of his companions while he watched.

Visitors to the U.S. Virgin Islands can visit either Blackbeard's Castle, said to have been used by Blackbeard and now a U.S. National Historic Landmark:
Or, on the other side of town, Bluebeard's Castle, a resort. It was supposedly built by Bluebeard for his love, Mericedita, who cheated on him, so he left her.
Aside from the pirate, other serial killers have been referred to in the press as Bluebeards, such as H.H. Holmes, who married bigamously and was convicted of killing 27 men, women, and children. His "murder castle," specifically designed with "labyrinthine corridors, chutes to the cellar, a vault disguised as a room, trapdoors, and dead ends" was referred to as "Bluebeard's Chamber of Horror." Henri Landru, Johann Otto Hoch, George Joseph Smith, and Ed Gein are other murderers with similar enough details to merit comparison.
Bluebeards are not limited to males-female serial kills of husbands (mostly for monetary gain) are also referred to as Lady Bluebeards, such as Belle Gunness and Lyda Trueblood.
Information was taken from the book Bluebeard: a Reader's Guide to the English Tradition by Casie E. Hermansson. This book was one of my Christmas presents...nothing like a nice morbid post to start off the new year, right?


  1. You really need to fix the hyphens. You probably meant them as long dashes, but that's not how they came out. Either use two or three of them, or put spaces around them.
    And "he would even light slow-burning fuse cords under his hat so that his beard would appear to be burning" doesn't make sense - he didn't light them under his hat, he lit them and tucked them under the edge of his hat.

    1. Thanks for pointing that out. I don't have the time to go back and fix every post in my archives, but I'll try to be more aware of that when I draft future posts!