And it is SO important for any folklorist (or amateur fairy tale nerd) to go beyond the most famous versions of the tales. We so often fall into the trap of analyzing all the details of the brothers Grimm or Perrault/Anderson versions of a tale without realizing that those details are not essential to the tale itself (and maybe weren't even present in the first edition of the Grimm tales, but added later as editorial choices). Only when studying multiple versions of the tales from various cultures do we start to see a picture emerge-what elements of the tales are found everywhere? What elements change with the culture?
I'll be sharing more from both of these books in the future, but for now enjoy this interesting, if not slightly disturbing, Frog Prince tale from Hungary:
The Wonderful Frog
"There was once, I don't know where, a man who had three daughters." One day the father told his eldest to fetch him some water out of the well. When the girl arrived, a huge frog called out to her from the bottom of the well, that he would not allow her to draw water until she threw him down her gold ring. The eldest refused to give her rings to such an ugly creature, and returned without water.
Next the father sent his second daughter, and the same thing happened. Finally the father sent his youngest, Betsie, pleading with her to find a way to save him from suffering thirst. Because Betsie was so fond of her father, she threw her ring down to the frog, and her father was delighted to have fresh water.
In the evening, the frog crawled out of the well and started banging on their door, crying, "Falther-in-law! Father-in-law! I should like something to eat." The father was angry, and told his daughters to give the frog a broken plate to gnaw on. But the frog demanded some roast meat on a tin plate, and afraid the frog would cast a spell on them otherwise, the father obliged. For the same reason, the father eventually gave in to the frog's demands for wine and a silk bed.
Next the frog demanded a girl. The father commanded his eldest daughter to lie down next to the frog, but she refused. So did the middle child. The frog croaked that he didn't want the other daughters, he wanted Betsie. "So Betsie went to bed with the frog, but her father thoughtfully left a lamp burning on the top of the oven; noticing which, the frog crawled out of bed and blew the lamp out." The father attempted twice more to light the lamp, but always thwarted by the frog, "was therefore obliged to leave his dear little Betsie in the dark by the side of the ugly frog, and felt great anxiety about her."
In the morning, the father and his two eldest daughters were astonished to find a handsome lad by Betsie's side. He asked for Betsie's hand, and they were married. The elder sisters were now envious of Betsie, and she herself was very happy.
Illustrations by Charles Robinson
Tale summarized by me; full tale available in the book
And no one simply stomped on the frog? :-) Yes, I think Surlalune is a wonderful web site. I first heard about it from Juliet Matillier at one of her workshops. I'd be happy to buy these books if they were available in ebook format, but my shelves are just too crowded to give in to the temptation of a print book.
ReplyDeleteThey are in Ebook and much more affordable if you're book budgeting. Prices are $5-$10 for each. Also, watch Heidi's site, she'll let you know if they are on sale
DeleteThis is actually a lot like the "Frog Prince" story that's in the first edition of Grimm but not the later versions. Not to be confused with "The Frog King; or Iron Henry" which is still in most versions.
ReplyDeleteThis is why I really want that book of first edition Grimms!
DeleteThis is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine.
ReplyDeletepandasilk.com
Great, i have no word i am quite happy
ReplyDeleteSG 11 Brain
I'm going to die for this pic
ReplyDeleteProflexoral xl
Joker338 merupakan Agen Judi Online Indonesia, yang senantiasa membantu para member dalam melakukan Daftar Joker123, Daftar Sbobet Casino, Daftar Sbobet dan Daftar S128.
ReplyDeleteSBOBET CASINO
JOKER123
SBOBET ONLINE
S128
ReplyDeleteSet the hour and minute for the online alarm clock. The alarm message will appear and the preselected sound will be played at the set time.
When setting the alarm, you can click the "Test" button to preview the alert and check the sound volume.
You can configure the alarm clock appearance (text color, type, and size), and these settings will be saved; they will be used when you open your web browser next time.
The online alarm clock will not work if you close your browser or shut down your computer, but it can work without an internet connection.
You can add links to online alarm clocks with different time settings to your browser's Favorites. Opening such a link will set the alarm clock to the predefined time.
KukuEpta
kukuepta.com
Buy youtube subscribers , buy youtube likes , buy youtube views , buy youtube comments
ReplyDeletehttps://popularking.com/product-category/youtube/
Buy Youtube Subscribers
Buy Youtube Likes
Buy Youtube Views
Buy Youtube Comments
We are Sock Manufacturer in China, Production custom socks and wholesaler are our main business. We specialize in high-performance athletic socks, fashion socks, compression and outdoor socks.
ReplyDeleteBest Online Deal For Socks, Try Today
Wholesale Socks
Sock Manufacturers
Socks Wholesale
Socks Factory
360 degree dash cam
ReplyDeletemini car camera
cheap 4k action camera
Ausek
ANC bluetooth headphones