Saturday, February 4, 2017

Awakening the Beauty

Everyone's familiar with the episode where the Prince comes and awakens Sleeping Beauty with a kiss; some people might be aware of older versions of the fairy tale that involve rape and childbirth; sensationalized articles and lists love to use those versions to shock people with the "real" and disturbing versions of classic tales.

While many of the older versions are indeed quite dark and disturbing, they don't all involve rape of an unconscious victim, and True Love's Kiss isn't always the solution in later tales. I used Surlalune's Sleeping Beauties Tales From Around the World book to gain a few different examples of how the Princess is actually awakened.

Going back to Norse mythology, the story of Brunhild (from the late late 13th century) is similar to a Sleeping Beauty tale. In it, the bravery of the hero Siegfried allows him to pass through the dangers and get close to Brunhild (although he doesn't actually do anything, the "vile flames fled in shame and dismay before the pure sunbeam flashes from Greyfell's mane"-so the real secret to heroism is apparently having a magical horse). Once there, he gives Brunhild a gentle kiss on the forehead (not even the lips) and softly calls her name, giving us the picture of an absolute gentleman. I find it ironic that this possibly oldest version of the tale is the closest to the Disney in terms of the stereotypical hero riding in on his horse, braving dangers, and saving the day with a kiss. From there we depart from that ideal-

It's the French story of Troylus and Zelladine from Perceforest, from some time in the 13th or 14th century, that we get to some of the horrific parts of the story. We read a description of how Troylus tries to resist temptation around the beautiful sleeping girl, but just can't help following "the tenets of Venus"-at least this version describes his actions as cowardly, and perhaps tries to justify it a little because Troylus "speaks a long discourse begging forgiveness for his grand liberties." Yet nine months later Zelladine gives birth to a son, who grabs her finger in an attempt to suckle, and suckles so hard that he sucks out the sleep thorn that kept her enchanted.

There are other, less well known Medieval stories which involve a maiden under an enchanted sleep. In almost all of them she is taken advantage of. In Pandragus et Libanor, the maiden is in an unnatural sleep, does not wake up during the night in question, but simply wakes up normally the next day. In Brother of Joy and Sister of Pleasure, the "hero" manages to wake the woman he impregnated with the help of a bird who gives a magic herb to the maiden. This is one of the rare stories in which the woman actually gets upset to find she has been taken advantage of (Zelladine also felt devastated upon waking)-most sleeping beauties seem strangely silent, even happy, to find themselves awakened with a strange lover and/or child-although in this story she does eventually grow to love her rapist (There are good reasons these stories aren't so well known today). Lastly, in the adventures of Blandin de Cornoalha the Knight, we find a chivalrous hero who is more like Siegfried-he falls in love but does not appear to succumb to temptation; rather breaks the enchantment through bravery; he learns he must defeat a serpent, obtain a white hawk, and bring the hawk to the side of the maiden.

Basile's Sun, Moon, and Talia (early 1600s) is very similar to "Troylus and Zelladine"-the only difference being that it is twins who suck the flax from her fingernail and not a single baby. It is this version which also introduces the next violent episode, with the attempted cannibalism of the children. In this version it's a little more understandable, though, because it's the Prince's wife that grows furious when she discovers the truth.

From there we move away from raping/nursing babies as the primary cause of awakening. In Perrault's 1697 classic version, the prince finds the princess and kneels at her side (no kiss) just as the 100 years of her curse happen to be ending, so his part in everything is pretty simple. Once the Princess awakes, they simply talk together for four hours, so it's perhaps the best example of love in a Sleeping Beauty tale. The brambles parted to let him through, so while he wasn't quite the brave knight in shining armor, it would have been pretty creepy to continue as the thorns closed again behind him and then again as he walked through the castle where everyone was eerily unconscious, so we'll give him credit for that. The cannibalism episode follows, only now it's the Prince's mother that is an ogress and wants to eat her grandchildren

In the Italian Sun, Pearl, and Anna, the hero simply removes a spindle from the grasp of the sleeping Anna. They have children together (followed by the cannibalistic mother in law again) but at least it's consensual; I find this transition (or lack thereof) to be downright humorous: "'How are you today, Anna?' 'Very well, thank you. And how are you, your majesty?' 'I'm well.' By the end of nine months, the girl was great with child."

There's another very brief, tragic Italian tale called The Son of a King in which the queen mother actually succeeds in cooking and eating her grandchildren and daughter in law (there is no mention of awakening or the princess actually being found asleep in this one, just that she was found in a deserted castle).

In the Grimm's Briar Rose, once again the hedge parts  for our hero (but this time the hedge is filled with corpses from others who attempted to pass before the time was up), and we have a Princess awakened with a kiss for the first time since Siegfried and Brunhild.

The Grimms also have another Sleeping Beauty tale, The Glass Coffin. I thought I had never read it before but it turns out not only had I read it, I wrote a whole post on it 5 years ago. This is why I have a memory is terrible! Anyway, it's a fascinating tale in which a Princess was cursed to sleep in a glass coffin because she spurned the advances of an evil magician-she had even attempted to shoot him but the bullet bounced off of him! A traveling tailor discovers her, and all he had to do was look at her, and she woke up and instructed him on how to open the coffin and free her. Afterwards, she gave him a "friendly kiss on his lips." This one wins the award for the most active female heroine!

In the Austrian The Enchanted Sleep, although the count's son does kiss the sleeping maiden, it doesn't appear to awaken her right away. He had also the foresight to write her a letter, which she later used to summon him to her, and also prove his innocence and his brothers' treachery (they had actually killed him, but animals he had helped along his journey came and healed him).

The Story of The Prince in Love is from Egypt, but bears similarities to older tales, particularly the cursed flax under the fingernail being what causes the sleep. Here, fortunately, the prince simply finds and removes the flax, and it's only after she wakes up that he spends forty days and nights with her in bed-although no children result from it. The prince is eventually a jerk to her though, so she decides to teach him a lesson-disguises herself with more beauty and causes him to fall in love with her again, but spurns his gifts, and will only marry him if he pretends to be dead and is himself carried around in a coffin. I'm not sure shy she wants to marry a man who thinks he's cheating on her, but it is interesting that he must have his own sort of "enchanted sleep" before they unite.

There's also The Petrified Mansion from India, in which the prince finds a stick of gold and just happens to touch the Princess' head with it, which revives her and the rest of the mansion's inhabitants. The curse was brought on by a stick of silver, so gold was the antidote-and the same gold stick later healed the Prince's parents, who were mourning their missing son.

So rather than bravery, many medieval Princes took advantage of sleeping princesses. Later, most Princes became more respectful of the enchanted women, who seemed more likely to be revived by chance than from getting a magical kiss. Some of the tales make us feel uncomfortable to read today, yet some were pretty feminist, featuring strong and brave women, and men who had self control. What other versions of Sleeping Beauty and methods of awakening are there? (I didn't even touch on Snow White tales here...)

Illustrations-A. H. Watson (first two), Millicent Sowerby (last two)


  1. I have heard of one Male sleeping beauty example, although it be considered a male equivalent of Snow White. Here is one site of this fairy tale

    1. What a fantastic tale! That one deserves its own post! Thanks for sharing. Do you happen to know the source? I can't find one

    2. I wasn't familiar with this story, either! Love it, thank you! I remember reading another sleeping prince story somewhere though, I want to say it was in Angela Carter's Book of Fairy Tales but I'm not certain...

      Also jealous you have the SurLaLune Sleeping Beauties book, it's hard to come by now! I hadn't heard of Sun, Pearl, and Anna. I take it the spindle is significant in putting Anna to sleep, too? And is the sleep foretold/given to her as a curse like in some other stories?

    3. I know I was shocked to see that the Surlalune Sleeping Beauties book is priced at $473 on Amazon!! And a lot of the texts aren't available online for copyright reasons, sadly.

      In Sun, Pearl, and Anna, a soothsayer predicted that the Princess would touch a spindle and fall under an enchantment when she turned 13-but for no apparent reason (no fairy was insulted or anything). She is kept underground but her nurse was still allowed to have a spindle there for some reason, and one day she was spinning when she thought the Princess was asleep, and of course she touched it out of curiosity. (Then there's also a part where her father has three dresses made for her, the dresses she would have had for her wedding day, and had her dressed in all three, one on top of the other...that part was alarmingly reminiscent of Donkeyskin to me!)

    4. Yes so expensive! I hope they reprint it sometime, strange that it's so rare compared to the others! That's really interesting, kind of like Sun, Moon & Talia with no slighted fairy then and the dresses are very Donkeyskin-esque indeed! Does it have the extra bit with the children and the cannibalistic mother/wife? From the title I'm guessing Sun and Pearl are the children?

    5. Also I found another source of the sleeping prince fairy tale. Apparently it's Spanish:

    6. Yes, Sun and Pearl are the children, and the queen also wants to eat them. Only in this one, Anna was suspicious of sending her children to her, unlike Talia who was glad to send her children to her mother in law. And as the queen demands Anna take off her clothes to boil her, each time Anna took off a dress (she still has the three dresses on from her father, years later) they made pealing noises that sound like church bells, and the Prince heard and came to the rescue.

      And, thanks for looking that up!

    7. Sounds like Anna is a bit wiser than Talia, then! And ahh I'd heard mention of the bells before relating to Sun, Moon and Talia but never found a version of the story which included them. So that explains it then, must have been Sun, Pearl and Anna instead!

      And no worries, it would be nice to find a more solid source for it though. I'll keep looking & let you know if anything turns up :)

  2. Hi, thanks for your lovely post. The source for the Sleeping Prince can be found in Alison Lurie's book "Clever Gretchen and Other Forgotten Folktales" (a fantastic book anyway). Apparently it's based on the story from a 1955 French collection by Paul Delarue, which was the translation from a Spanish collection of 1886 by Sergio Hernandez de Soto. What a brilliant story!

  3. At MyAssignmentHelp, we certainly value what our customers believe about our online assignment help service; as for that specific reason, delivering quality assignments on time is our first priority.